Cast Iron Pizza With Butter Chicken – Gluten Free

Published on Feb 04, 2021

  by   Kristina Stosek

1 reviews

Prep Time: 20 minutes Cook Time: 35 minutes Serves: 14-inch pizza
Add a Rating
​This post may contain affiliate links, please see our privacy policy for details

This cast iron pizza with butter chicken has the crispiest, crunchiest crust, just as if you made it in a pizza oven. The topping is made with the creamiest butter chicken and buffalo mozzarella cheese.

butter chicken pizza on a cast iron skillet

The tender chicken is smothered in an Indian inspired sauce that sets this cast iron pizza apart from most. The buffalo mozzarella adds an extra creaminess that goes deliciously well with the butter chicken.

I don’t know where to start here! This cast iron pizza recipe is not your typical pizza. I combined Indian flavours with a classic crispy pizza crust. A little different, I know, but believe me, it is sooo good!

If you love authentic food such as Indian, this pizza will satisfy both the pizza and the Indian cravings. 

Cast Iron Pizza With Butter Chicken Recipe Details

Today I wanted to share something different. I was getting tired of the same old classics. Indian food such as butter chicken is often served with naan bread, so why not butter chicken on a pizza?

To keep the sauce extra creamy, I topped the pizza with buffalo mozzarella. Yes, you could use mozzarella cheese, but it will not give you the creaminess. I feel that the cheese made this pizza extra special.


slice buffalo mozzarella on a plate


Difference between mozzarella and buffalo mozzarella?

Mozzarella cheese is firmer and is mostly made from cow’s milk. On the other hand, buffalo mozzarella is softer, creamier and a lot more flavourful and is made from water buffalo milk.

Water buffalos milk has nearly twice the fat content of cows milk making buffalo mozzarella superior to mozzarella made from cows milk.

Let’s talk about cast iron pan for pizza

To date, I have not found a better way to make gluten-free pizza crust than the one I made today on a cast iron pizza pan. When it comes to gluten-free pizza, because the dough doesn’t have gluten, which is vital in making pizza, the pizza will not crisp up as beautifully as if you were making a pizza crust with gluten.

This is where the cast iron pizza pan comes in.

Cast iron pizza pan comes with a thicker base for excellent heat retention and an even heat distribution to create that crispy restaurant-style crust you could only get if the pizza is made in a pizza oven.

The cast-iron pan fortifies food with iron, which helps in your iron intake an essential mineral that our body needs.

When the cast iron pan is properly seasoned, it forms a non-stick surface allowing you to cook with less fat. And the best part about this cast iron pizza pan is that you can use it to make tortillas, quesadillas, and eggs.

The cast iron pan is also excellent for searing, grilling, broiling, roasting, BBQ grills and even open campfire. I wish I got mine earlier because there are so many uses for this easy to clean and maintain cast iron pan.


sliced butter chicken pizza on a cast iron skillet


What if you don’t have a cast iron pizza pan?

I would recommend using a pizza pan with a perforated surface, pizza stone or cast-iron skillet. But I can honestly say this cast iron pizza pan has become my favourite kitchen essential.

Gluten free yeast free pizza dough

I used my easy go to gluten-free, yeast free pizza dough in this butter chicken pizza recipe. I like using a simple pizza dough when the topping is rich and flavourful. Plus, the dough is super easy to whip up, virtually five minutes.


butter chicken pieces in a skillet


Butter chicken pizza topping

As I mentioned earlier, this is not your typical pizza – it is better! To make the butter chicken topping is super easy. First, you marinate the chicken in an Indian spiced yogurt marinade.

While the chicken is marinating, make the sauce by sauteing onions, then add spices, tomatoes, coconut milk and lime juice. Once the sauce starts to simmer, transfer the chicken with the marinade into the sauce and cook for 10 minutes. Done.


1 slice of gluten free butter chicken pizza on a plate


I pre-bake the pizza crust for 10 minutes before I add the topping. The reason I did this, it kept the crust deliciously crunchy without becoming soggy.

Then the final topping, my favourite buffalo mozzarella, makes everything creamier and super flavourful. It is like adding cream to the butter chicken. It doesn’t get any better than this!

Leave a Comment


1 pound thinly sliced skinless chicken breast or a thigh Ruth


How much chicken does this require?

Add a Rating

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *